▲ 1st
Charlie Maxwell singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Harvey Kuenn scores. Al Kaline scores.
2–0
▲ 2nd
Al Kaline triples (4) on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Ozzie Virgil scores. Red Wilson scores. Frank Lary scores.
5–0
▲ 2nd
Gail Harris singles on a to right fielder Hank Bauer. Al Kaline scores.
6–0
▲ 3rd
Red Wilson singles on a to left fielder Norm Siebern. Ozzie Virgil scores. Red Wilson to 2nd.
7–0
▲ 4th
Gail Harris triples (3). Al Kaline scores.
8–0
▲ 4th
Charlie Maxwell out on a sacrifice fly to left fielder Norm Siebern. Gail Harris scores.
9–0
▼ 7th
Bobby Richardson grounds into a force out, second baseman Milt Bolling to shortstop Billy Martin. Jerry Lumpe scores. Elston Howard out at 2nd. Bobby Richardson to 1st.
9–1
▼ 7th
Marv Throneberry out, pitcher Frank Lary to first baseman Gail Harris. Bobby Richardson scores. Don Larsen to 2nd.
9–2
▼ 8th
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (24).
9–3
▼ 8th
Elston Howard singles on a to left fielder Charlie Maxwell. Bill Skowron scores. Jerry Lumpe to 2nd.
9–4
▲ 9th
Gail Harris triples (4) on a to right fielder Marv Throneberry. Billy Martin scores. Tito Francona scores.
11–4
▲ 9th
Ozzie Virgil singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Gail Harris scores. Charlie Maxwell to 2nd.
12–4
▼ 9th
Marv Throneberry hits a home run (3).
12–5