▼ 1st
Bill Tuttle out on a sacrifice fly to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Harvey Kuenn scores.
0–1
▲ 2nd
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (17).
1–1
▲ 2nd
Joe Collins hits a home run (2).
2–1
▲ 3rd
Hank Bauer doubles (3) on a to left fielder Charlie Maxwell. Billy Martin scores.
3–1
▲ 3rd
Mickey Mantle singles on a to right fielder Al Kaline. Hank Bauer scores. Mickey Mantle to 3rd. Mickey Mantle advances to 3rd, on a fielding error by right fielder Al Kaline.
4–1
▲ 3rd
Andy Carey out to right fielder Al Kaline.
5–1
▼ 4th
Harvey Kuenn singles on a to right fielder Hank Bauer. Frank House scores. Jim Brideweser to 3rd. Wayne Belardi to 2nd.
5–2
▼ 4th
Earl Torgeson singles on a to right fielder Hank Bauer. Jim Brideweser scores. Wayne Belardi scores. Harvey Kuenn to 2nd.
5–4
▲ 5th
Eddie Robinson hits a grand slam (1). Hank Bauer scores. Mickey Mantle scores. Joe Collins scores.
9–4
▲ 5th
Andy Carey hits a home run (2).
10–4
▲ 9th
Mickey Mantle singles on a to left fielder Charlie Maxwell. Gil McDougald scores. Billy Martin to 2nd.
11–4