▼ 1st
Walt Dropo doubles (9) on a to left fielder Irv Noren. Harvey Kuenn scores. Ray Boone scores.
0–2
▼ 3rd
Hoot Evers singles on a to right fielder Hank Bauer. Harvey Kuenn scores. Bill Tuttle to 3rd.
0–3
▼ 3rd
Ray Boone flies into a sacrifice double play, left fielder Irv Noren to second baseman Gil McDougald. Bill Tuttle scores. Hoot Evers out at 2nd.
0–4
▲ 4th
Gil McDougald hits a home run (9). Mickey Mantle scores.
2–4
▼ 4th
Frank Bolling singles on a to left fielder Irv Noren. Red Wilson scores. Frank Bolling to 2nd. Fielding error by left fielder Irv Noren.
2–5
▲ 5th
Irv Noren out on a sacrifice fly to center fielder Bill Tuttle. Enos Slaughter scores.
3–5
▲ 5th
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (24). Hank Bauer scores.
5–5
▼ 5th
Ray Boone hits a home run (17). Bill Tuttle scores. Hoot Evers scores.
5–8
▲ 7th
Irv Noren out, first baseman Walt Dropo to pitcher Al Aber. Gene Woodling scores. Hank Bauer to 3rd.
6–8
▲ 7th
Yogi Berra singles on a to center fielder Bill Tuttle. Hank Bauer scores.
7–8
▲ 8th
Irv Noren singles on a to center fielder Bill Tuttle. Jerry Coleman scores. Johnny Sain to 2nd.
8–8
▼ 10th
Jim Delsing hits a home run (3). Red Wilson scores.
8–10