▲ 1st
Ray Boone grounds into a double play, shortstop Phil Rizzuto to second baseman Billy Martin to first baseman Joe Collins. Harvey Kuenn scores. Fred Hatfield out at 2nd. Ray Boone out at 1st.
1–0
▲ 2nd
Steve Souchock grounds into a double play, shortstop Phil Rizzuto to second baseman Billy Martin to first baseman Joe Collins. Bob Nieman scores. Walt Dropo out at 2nd. Steve Souchock out at 1st.
2–0
▼ 2nd
Phil Rizzuto triples (3) on a to right fielder Steve Souchock. Mickey Mantle scores. Billy Martin scores.
2–2
▼ 2nd
Jim McDonald singles on a to pitcher Billy Hoeft. Phil Rizzuto scores.
2–3
▲ 3rd
Ray Boone singles on a to left fielder Gene Woodling. Harvey Kuenn scores. Fred Hatfield to 2nd.
3–3
▼ 5th
Yogi Berra singles on a to left fielder Bob Nieman. Hank Bauer scores.
3–4
▼ 7th
Joe Collins doubles (10) on a to right fielder Steve Souchock. Gil McDougald scores.
3–5
▼ 7th
Hank Bauer singles on a to left fielder Bob Nieman. Joe Collins scores.
3–6
▼ 7th
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (20). Hank Bauer scores. Yogi Berra scores.
3–9
▼ 7th
Billy Martin singles on a to left fielder Bob Nieman. Gene Woodling scores.
3–10
▼ 7th
Phil Rizzuto doubles (20) on a to center fielder Jim Delsing. Billy Martin scores.
3–11
▼ 7th
Gil McDougald out to right fielder Steve Souchock. Phil Rizzuto scores.
3–12
▲ 8th
Steve Souchock singles on a to right fielder Hank Bauer. Ray Boone scores. Jim Delsing to 2nd.
4–12
▼ 8th
Gene Woodling triples (4) on a to left fielder Bob Nieman. Hank Bauer scores. Gene Woodling out at home on the throw, left fielder Bob Nieman to shortstop Harvey Kuenn to catcher Johnny Bucha.
4–13