▲ 1st
Harvey Kuenn singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Billy Hitchcock scores.
1–0
▲ 1st
Walt Dropo out to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Harvey Kuenn scores.
2–0
▼ 2nd
Hank Bauer singles on a to center fielder Jim Delsing. Mickey Mantle scores.
2–1
▼ 3rd
Gil McDougald reaches on a fielding error by left fielder Don Lund. Ed Lopat scores. Gil McDougald out at 3rd on the throw, left fielder Don Lund to shortstop Harvey Kuenn to third baseman Billy Hitchcock.
2–2
▲ 5th
Don Lund singles on a to left fielder Gene Woodling. Billy Hitchcock scores. Harvey Kuenn to 2nd.
3–2
▲ 5th
Jim Delsing hit by pitch. Harvey Kuenn scores. Don Lund to 3rd. Bob Nieman to 2nd.
4–2
▲ 5th
Jerry Priddy doubles (3) on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Don Lund scores. Bob Nieman scores. Jim Delsing scores.
7–2
▼ 5th
Gil McDougald triples (1) on a to center fielder Jim Delsing. Bill Renna scores. Joe Collins scores.
7–4
▼ 5th
Mickey Mantle singles on a to shortstop Harvey Kuenn. Gil McDougald scores.
7–5
▲ 6th
Don Lund doubles (7) on a to left fielder Gene Woodling. Billy Hitchcock scores. Harvey Kuenn to 3rd.
8–5
▼ 6th
Joe Collins hits a home run (2). Irv Noren scores.
8–7
▼ 8th
Joe Collins grounds into a force out, second baseman Jerry Priddy to shortstop Harvey Kuenn. Yogi Berra scores. Art Schult out at 2nd. Joe Collins to 1st.
8–8
▼ 9th
Gene Woodling singles on a to left fielder Don Lund. Billy Martin scores. Mickey Mantle to 3rd. Hank Bauer to 2nd.
8–9